20080515 Westminster Eagle: Pictures are worth a thousand words but not the whole picture by Kevin Dayhoff

Pictures are worth a thousand words, but not the whole picture

http://news.mywebpal.com/news_tool_v2.cfm?pnpID=978&NewsID=902610&CategoryID=18317&show=localnews&om=1

05/15/08 By Kevin E. Dayhoff

Last Wednesday, the Humane Society of the United States released videotape of an "undercover investigation" which claimed to show the "shocking abuse of 'downer' cows occurs not just at slaughter plants but É at livestock auctions and stockyards around the country," according to the humane society press release.

One of the stockyards "investigated" was the Westminster Livestock Auction.

In a carefully choreographed press conference, Humane Society President Wayne Pacelle played the video shot at the WLA and said: "This is just pitiful. É This poor creature, too weak to move, just left there to languish and to die."

In the first seconds of the video, a cow that is unable to walk is shown in the unloading gate at the livestock auction.

In an interview last Thursday, Jim Horak Sr., owner of the livestock auction since 2004, said a hired trucker unloaded the cow at a busy moment that evening; just as "the man who handles the gate was (away) moving other cattle that had just been unloaded."

When the gatekeeper returned minutes later, just after the cow was unloaded; he found the cow down. Horak said that upon being told that the auction did not accept livestock that cannot walk, the driver refused to take the cow back and quickly left.

The cow was immediately, "carefully," moved outside of the gate and offered alfalfa hay, according to Horak. Meanwhile, the owner of the cow was called and told the WLA would not accept delivery of the cow and that the owner had to come back and pick up the animal. The owner refused, Horak said.

Horak said he has handled thousands of animals and no one -- until the Humane Society of the United States -- questioned him before about how the yard handles animals.

Indeed, one of the immediate mysteries about this incident is how a Humane Society undercover investigator happened to be there for the brief period when this particular cow, out of thousands of animals, was still in the unloading chute.

The fact that the cow was humanely moved is obvious. One critical advocacy of the humane society is that diseased and sick cows are being inhumanely "dragged and prodded with inhumane handling methods, and increasing the threat of carrying and passing disease."

I can imagine that if the cow had been handled inhumanely it would have appeared on the "undercover" video.

Later in the week, Fox 5 television reported that the Humane Society of the United States knew the cow was not sick or diseased and in fact knew the cow had just had an operation for a twisted stomach.

One has to wonder -- how the Humane Society knew that piece of information?

The day following the auction, the Humane Society said the cow "was filmed by ... investigators in an advanced state of physical distress. Her breathing was labored and she flailed helplessly on the ground. She had no protection from the elements and was without food or water for almost a day."

However, Horak said that in spite of the fact that it could not stand (because of the surgery), the cow was not in distress.

As far as the cow staying outside overnight; that's what cows do. They rarely, if ever, come into the farmhouse to watch TV at night.

Furthermore, Horak said an employee checked on the cow at daybreak the next morning and gave it water and hay.

The cow died. Hours after the video was shot, the Humane Society of the United States called the local humane society which came out and euthanized the cow. The national Humane Society branch then put a picture of the dead cow on its press release.

If I ever have stomach surgery, please don't take a video of me not being able to walk; then claim that I've been abused and have me euthanized by the Humane Society.

Also, just FYI, I'd prefer not to have a picture of my dead body on a press release.

In a statement last Wednesday, the Maryland Department of Agriculture said it is investigating. That's fine. Perhaps they'll include in their review the Humane Society of the United States' "undercover investigation."

Kevin Dayhoff writes from Westminster. E-mail him at: kdayhoff at carr.org.